Resurfaced footage of ‘America’s Subsequent High Mannequin’ judges calling a contestant ‘fats’ has gone viral

  • Footage exhibiting “America’s Subsequent High Mannequin” judges discussing one contestant’s physique has gone viral.

  • It exhibits a number of clips from the present’s first season, specializing in “plus-sized” mannequin Robynne Manning.

  • A TikTok person posted the video, saying their “mistreatment” of Manning was “appalling.”

Outdated footage exhibiting judges on the truth present competitors “America’s Subsequent High Mannequin” discussing one contestant’s physique has gone viral after a TikToker referred to as the feedback “unacceptable.”

A compilation of footage from the present was posted on July 12 by TikToker @hotgirlseurope. It features a sequence of clips from the present’s first season, which was broadcast in 2003, through which fashions and judges Tyra Banks and Janice Dickinson repeatedly criticize 26-year-old contestant Robynne Manning’s dimension and weight. Manning was referred to as “Robin” on the present.


In a single clip, Banks stated she had a “downside” with Manning as a result of her higher physique “would not match” her decrease physique.

Dickinson stated, “Robynne’s out, so far as I am involved, about being a supermodel. That is my humble opinion. I feel that subsequent America’s high mannequin just isn’t a plus-sized mannequin, I am sorry.” Dickinson additionally calls Manning “fats” and says, “She’s big, she’s not going to be a high mannequin,” and, “She needs to be working at Avis.”

Manning was additionally criticized when she refused to take part in a nude photoshoot which she stated made her really feel “uncomfortable,” and may very well be seen crying after Banks requested her to not cowl her physique backstage when she was carrying a showering swimsuit.

The TikTok has acquired practically a million views and 124,000 likes. An Instagram account that seems to belong to Manning has additionally reposted the clip, together with the caption, “Response coming SOON!” Insider was unable to substantiate the account belongs to Manning.

TikTok viewers expressed outrage on the resurfaced clips

Most of the feedback beneath the TikTok video voiced outrage at how the “ANTM” judges handled Manning, in addition to their classification of her as “plus-size.”

There may be some debate concerning the time period “plus dimension” in modeling, which sometimes refers to fashions over a US dimension 6. A examine performed in 2016 and revealed within the Worldwide Journal of Style Design, Know-how and Schooling discovered that the typical gown dimension for a girl within the US was 16 to 18.

Plus-size vogue influencer Stephanie Yeboah beforehand commented on the difficulty, calling out vogue manufacturers who use mid-size fashions for “plus-size” campaigns.

One particular person on TikTok commented, “Wow… I have to be within the class of ‘elephant’ then as a regular UK dimension 12-14. Completely stunning that they are saying she’s ‘plus-sized.’ She is gorgeous.”

A number of feedback additionally referred to as for “justice” for Manning and stated they thought the present didn’t age effectively.

The clip additionally went viral on Twitter, the place it acquired a blended response

The video was additionally shared on Twitter, the place it has over 16,000 quote tweets and 242,000 likes. 


The quote-tweets mirror most of the feedback on TikTok, with one particular person writing, “I’ll by no means forgive the showrunners of ‘ANTM’ for the way in which they psychologically abused the fashions and (by proxy) their younger feminine viewers.”

Many individuals took problem with Dickinson’s feedback, saying that she was simply as a lot accountable as Banks, who introduced and produced the present, for her angle in the direction of Manning, with one arguing she was “paid to tear ladies down.”

Some folks argued that the clips had been a product of the occasions, and the narrative round ladies’s our bodies 19 years in the past had been totally different, though one other recommended issues aren’t all that totally different at present, as “the judging and policing of girls’s our bodies is in each nook and cranny of our society proper now.”

Tyra Banks has confronted criticism up to now for the way in which contestants had been handled on “America’s Subsequent High Mannequin.”The CW/Hulu

This isn’t the primary time Banks and the present have come below hearth for the way in which contestants had been handled. In 2020 quite a lot of clips exhibiting problematic messaging about race, sexual orientation, and physique picture resurfaced on social media, resulting in widespread backlash. Earlier contestants have additionally described the present as “psychological warfare” and instructed Insider it brought about actual hurt.

On the time, Banks apologized and agreed that the present had its points and co-creator Ken Mok seconded her assertion and stated that elements of the present make him “cringe.”

Representatives for Dickinson, Banks, and Gauthier didn’t instantly reply to Insider’s request for remark. Manning didn’t instantly reply to Insider’s request for remark.

For extra tales like this, take a look at protection from Insider’s Digital Tradition workforce right here.

Learn the unique article on Insider

Supply hyperlink

Previous post Japanese Trend Designer Issey Miyake Lifeless At 84
Next post Our favourite 15 pictures from Tuesday on the 2022 Jackson County Truthful